I've seen half of Superbowl game once so I'd have no idea what to do if someone handed me a controller and told to play some Madden. I used to play a ton, and I mean A TON, of FIFA and Pro Evolution Soccer back in the day, probably thousands of hours. Unfortunately, I don't have time for it anymore. When I do decide to play a video game these days it's usually a short, story-driven indie game that I can finish in one afternoon. Here's a recent example:
The game is hauntingly beautiful and it's a fun little puzzle platformer. The story is interesting though frustratingly vague, though there's a big payoff at the end that has the potential to make grown men cry.